Close Menu
Metropolitan Airport NewsMetropolitan Airport News
  • Airport News
    • Publisher’s Message
    • Editor’s Notebook
    • Fast Five
    • On Duty
    • Air Cargo
    • Airline News
    • Airport Community
    • Airport Employment News
    • Airport Safety & Security
    • Company Spotlight
    • Ground Services
    • Intermodal
    • New York Aviation History
    • Non-Rev Traveler
  • Airport & Aviation Events
  • Airport Employment
  • Latest Issue
  • Login

Subscribe for Updates

Get the latest local airport and aviation news delivered right into your inbox each week!

News Updates
JFK Airport International Shoppes

New York-Area Hunger Relief Organizations Team Up with JFK-Based International Shoppes to Help Fight Hunger 

November 30, 2023
NTO_Rendering

E-J Is the EPC for JFK’s New Terminal One (NTO) Microgrid Project

November 29, 2023

Avianca Reinforces Executive Leadership Team

November 29, 2023
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Metropolitan Airport NewsMetropolitan Airport News
  • Airport News
    • Publisher’s Message
    • Editor’s Notebook
    • Fast Five
    • On Duty
    • Air Cargo
    • Airline News
    • Airport Community
    • Airport Employment News
    • Airport Safety & Security
    • Company Spotlight
    • Ground Services
    • Intermodal
    • New York Aviation History
    • Non-Rev Traveler
  • Airport & Aviation Events
  • Airport Employment
  • Latest Issue
  • Login
Metropolitan Airport NewsMetropolitan Airport News
Home»Airport News»Is Airport Temperature Screening a Violation of Rights?
Airport News

Is Airport Temperature Screening a Violation of Rights?

Joseph AlbaBy Joseph AlbaJune 26, 2020No Comments4 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

A lone traveler enters an empty baggage claim area in Terminal Four at Sky Harbor International Airport in Phoenix. Airlines are reducing flights due to the coronavirus COVID-19 outbreak.

Travis LeBlanc, a board member for an independent federal agency charged with protecting Americans’ privacy and civil liberties, asked the U.S. Department of Homeland Security to detail how it intends to collect, use and safeguard the sensitive health information. 

LeBlanc sought answers to a dozen questions about the government’s yet-unpublished airport screening plan.

“The ongoing pandemic is not a hall pass to disregard the privacy and civil liberties of the traveling public,” wrote LeBlanc, a Democrat on the five-member bipartisan Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board. 

The agency, created in the aftermath of the 9/11 attack to counter government overstepping in the fight against terrorism, has been investigating the use of body measurement calculations, such as facial recognition and fingerprinting technology, in airport security. 

In April, scientists at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention objected to a White House plan to check travelers’ temperatures in 20 U.S. airports, noting that earlier CDC-led efforts to screen travelers returning from China had failed to stop the virus from reaching the United States. In internal emails obtained by USA TODAY, CDC officers highlighted the high percentage of COVID-19 infections in people who never spiked a fever as one reason restarting the screenings would not work.  

LeBlanc cited the article in his letter and asked how the Department of Homeland Security has determined that temperature screenings would improve the safety of air travel. The federal government has not yet released a plan to screen for fevers for domestic travel and its status is unclear. Neither DHS, nor the CDC, responded to requests for additional information.  

LeBlanc said he understands the concept has been piloted at Dulles International Airport. He is concerned, however, that he has not seen a required privacy impact assessment. He also questioned the legal authority of the Transportation Security Administration to execute health screenings without trained medical workers, especially since those workers may face safety risks in performing the checks.  

“The program seems designed at TSA to increase the perception that traveling is safe,” LeBlanc said in an interview, “and the risk of that sort of security theater is it creates a false sense of security in people believing that there aren’t COVID-19 infected passengers that are on their flights.” 

President Donald Trump has signaled support for some form of health screenings, which airlines hope will convince people it is safe to travel again. Discount carrier Frontier already has started using a touchless thermometer to screen all passengers and crew before they board flights. Anyone with a fever of 100.4 degrees Fahrenheit or higher is not allowed to fly. 

Wide-ranging privacy concerns are emerging from the coronavirus epidemic. A bipartisan bill introduced in the U.S. Senate by Democrat Maria Cantwell of Washington state and Republican Bill Cassidy of Louisiana seeks to protect consumers who are using newly developed apps designed to track their exposure to people with COVID-19. 

It also would mandate a review of government practices during the pandemic by the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board. Cantwell previously has called for national guidelines on safety protections for airport travelers and workers. 

The American Civil Liberties Union also has expressed concern about using temperature screenings to detect and protect against the COVID-19 virus in a wide range of settings, from workplaces to hospitals, particularly when there is no vaccine.

For starters, people can spike fevers for many reasons unrelated to the new virus, including other illnesses, stress and hormonal changes.

Jay Stanley, an ACLU senior policy analyst, noted that the technology under consideration to conduct mass temperature screenings is not always accurate.  Airplanes present unique challenges, with travelers crammed close together for long periods of time. “Nobody wants to be on an airplane next to somebody who is infectious with COVID,” he said. 

But kicking anyone off may be equally fraught, Stanley added, saying, “It is a serious business to deny people their right to travel.”

Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
Joseph Alba
  • Website
  • LinkedIn

Mr. Alba was previously Editor of the Airport Press for 12 years covering both local as well as global aviation news. Prior to this, Mr. Alba had Executive positions in Systems Engineering and Marketing with IBM World Trade, and had foreign assignments in the Far East and Latin America earning three Outstanding Achievement Awards. Mr. Alba also directed a new function dealing with Alternate Fuels for Public Service Electric & Gas company in New Jersey and founded a Natural Gas Vehicle Consortium consisting of car company executives and fleet owners, and NGV suppliers in New Jersey. Mr. Alba was a founding partner of ATA, an IT Consulting company which is still active in Central and South America. After leaving the armed forces, Mr. Alba’s initial employee was the U.S. Defense Department as an analyst.

RELATED NEWS & UPDATES

NTO_Rendering

E-J Is the EPC for JFK’s New Terminal One (NTO) Microgrid Project

November 29, 2023
LGA Terminal-B Turkey encouraging kids to eat ONLY their vegetable!

LGA Terminal B Turkey Greets Travelers

November 22, 2023
JFK T8 Commercial Redevelopment

JFK T8 Concessions Outreach Events Highlight Upcoming Airport Opportunities

November 20, 2023

Modern Aviation Breaks Ground on Hangar Development at Republic Airport

November 16, 2023
PANYNJ Announces Opening of LaGuardia Business & Conference Center

PANYNJ Announces Opening of Atrium Business & Conference Center at LaGuardia Airport

October 18, 2023
PANYNJ Unveils New Construction Facility at JFK Airport

PANYNJ Unveils New Construction Facility at JFK Airport

September 29, 2023
Add A Comment

Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

AIRPORT & AVIATION EVENTS
LAAMCO Holiday Party
December 01, 2023
Il Bacco Ristorante
Little Neck, New York
JFK Airport Committee (JFKAC) Quarterly Meeting
December 04, 2023
7:00 PM to 9:00 PM
JFK Airport Hiring Event
December 06, 2023
9:30 AM to 3:00 PM
  • John F. Kennedy International Airport-(JFK)
Jamaica, New York
  • >> More Airport & Aviation Events

Subscribe for Weekly Email Updates

Get the latest local airport news, events, and jobs delivered right into your inbox each week.

Metropolitan Airport News provides timely news, information and updates for both Port Authority of New York & New Jersey (PANYNJ) employees and businesses that provide services at, and around the major New York airports (JFK, LGA, EWR).

John F. Kennedy International Airport
PO Box 300877
Jamaica, NY 11430 USA
Phone: (718) 750-4441
Email Us

Facebook X (Twitter) YouTube LinkedIn Flickr
November 2023 Issue
Metropolitan Airport News - November 2023
LATEST COMMENTS
  • Brian Keene on The TWA Flight Center
  • Rafael Perez on The TWA Flight Center
  • Maria Press on Bruges, Belgium, “The Dream City”
  • L Corwin on John F. Kennedy International Airport and Its Rich Air Cargo History
  • About Us
  • Advertising Options
  • Charitable Giving Program
  • Back Issue Archive
  • Contact Us
© 2023 Airport Media, Inc. All rights reserved.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.